Double opt-in, simply explained: how to put your newsletter on solid ground
Double opt-in means that anyone who signs up for your newsletter first receives a confirmation email and is only subscribed once they click the link inside it. That way you can be sure the email address really belongs to the person who signed up. In Germany, it’s considered the standard way to prove consent for email marketing.
What double opt-in means
“Opt-in” roughly means “actively choosing to take part”. With a single opt-in, someone enters their address and goes straight onto the list. Double opt-in adds a second step: the address entered receives an email with a confirmation link, and only people who click it are subscribed.
The idea behind it is simple. Anyone can type any address into a form, whether by mistake with a typo or deliberately using someone else’s address. Clicking the link in the confirmation email shows that the person has access to that inbox and really wants to sign up.
Why it matters for email marketing
Under Section 7(2) No. 2 of the German Unfair Competition Act (UWG), advertising by electronic mail without prior express consent counts as an unreasonable nuisance. A newsletter with offers is advertising, so you need consent before you send it.
The General Data Protection Regulation adds to this: under Art. 7(1) GDPR, the controller must be able to demonstrate that the person has given consent. So the burden of proof lies with you as the sender, not with the person receiving your email. No law expressly requires double opt-in, but it’s the usual way to provide this proof.
Section 7(3) UWG sets out an exception: if your customer gave you their email address when buying goods or a service from you, you may, under strict conditions, advertise your own similar products – as long as they haven’t objected and are clearly told about their right to object, both when the address is collected and in every email. This exception doesn’t cover a general newsletter sent to new prospects.
What Germany’s Federal Court of Justice has said
The Federal Court of Justice (BGH) looked at the process in its ruling of 10 February 2011 (case no. I ZR 164/09, “Double-opt-in-Verfahren”). It ruled that a confirmed email address does not prove consent to promotional phone calls, so the process isn’t enough for telephone marketing. For email marketing, however, the court considered double opt-in a suitable process. One thing still matters: the advertiser must document the consent in full.
A second ruling concerns the content of automated emails: on 15 December 2015 (case no. VI ZR 134/15), the Federal Court of Justice ruled that advertising in an automated acknowledgement of receipt can be unlawful if the recipient has expressly objected to advertising. In practice, this means keeping your double opt-in confirmation email factual and free of advertising.
How a proper double opt-in works
There are five steps from the form to your first newsletter:
- Sign-up form: the person enters their email address. The consent box isn’t ticked in advance, and the text names the sender, the content and roughly how often you’ll write, and points to the right to withdraw and to the privacy policy.
- Confirmation email: a factual email goes to the address straight away, with a “Confirm subscription” link and no advertising.
- Click: the subscription only takes effect once the link has been clicked. Unconfirmed addresses don’t receive a newsletter.
- Record: you log when the person signed up, when they confirmed, the exact consent text and the source (for example, which form they used).
- Newsletter: every issue includes an unsubscribe link, so unsubscribing is just as easy as signing up.
What your proof should include
The Federal Commissioner for Data Protection and Freedom of Information (BfDI) points out that consent must be documented in full. In practice, this list has proved its worth:
- Email address and time of sign-up
- Exact wording of the consent text the person saw (with version or date)
- Where the sign-up happened, such as which page or form
- Time the confirmation email was sent
- Time of the confirmation click
- Any later withdrawal: when and how
Example: what your confirmation email could look like
The confirmation email is short, friendly and contains only what relates to the sign-up. Here’s an example for a bakery:
Subject: “Please confirm your subscription to the Müller Bakery newsletter”. Text: “Hi, you’ve just signed up for our newsletter – about once a month, with new cakes, offers and dates. Please confirm your subscription by clicking the button. If you didn’t sign up, just ignore this email and you won’t hear from us.” Below that, the “Confirm subscription” button, the legal notice (Impressum) and a link to the privacy policy.
Common pitfalls are a pre-ticked box in the form, a voucher or offer right in the confirmation email, and newsletter consent that’s tied to something else, such as a giveaway or a download. Keep these things clearly separate.
Easy to unsubscribe – just as important as signing up
Under Art. 7(3) GDPR, consent can be withdrawn at any time, and withdrawing it must be as easy as giving it. For newsletters, the BfDI stresses that unsubscribing must be no more complicated than subscribing. A single click on an unsubscribe link in every email does this best: no login, no reason, no detours.
A final note: this guide explains the basics and isn’t legal advice. If you’re unsure how this applies to your business, ask a lawyer or your chamber.
How tiaki helps you
With tiaki, you build landing pages with a form and double opt-in, and the confirmation is sent automatically. Every new contact is saved in your Contacts with proof of consent, and every email you send includes an unsubscribe link.
Your questions answered.
Is double opt-in required by law?
Not expressly. For email marketing, though, you need prior express consent (Section 7(2) No. 2 UWG) and must be able to prove it (Art. 7(1) GDPR). Double opt-in is the usual way to do that.
Can the confirmation email contain advertising?
It’s best to keep it free of advertising. Its only job is to confirm the sign-up. Courts have sometimes found advertising in automated emails to be unlawful, for example the BGH on 15 Dec 2015 (VI ZR 134/15).
Is double opt-in enough for promotional calls too?
No. On 10 Feb 2011 (I ZR 164/09), the BGH ruled that an email address confirmed via double opt-in does not prove consent to telephone marketing.
What happens to addresses that are never confirmed?
They don’t receive a newsletter. Delete unconfirmed addresses after a short while so you aren’t keeping data for no purpose.
Is this guide legal advice?
No. It explains the basics in plain English. For your particular case, speak to a lawyer or your chamber.
Further reading.
- German Unfair Competition Act (UWG), Section 7 Unreasonable nuisance
- General Data Protection Regulation (EU) 2016/679, Art. 7 – Conditions for consent
- BGH, ruling of 10 Feb 2011 – I ZR 164/09 (“Double-opt-in-Verfahren”)
- BGH, ruling of 15 Dec 2015 – VI ZR 134/15 (advertising in an automated confirmation email)
- BfDI: Newsletters
You might also like.
Comments become customers. All by themselves.
tiaki automations: pick a goal, answer three questions, done. Reply to comments, send links, collect contacts. The ManyChat alternative.
Learn more FeatureEveryone who gets in touch. In one place.
Your little CRM: contacts are created from messages, comments and forms, with history, tags, consent records and export.
Learn more FeatureYour emails. Your name. Safely delivered.
Emails in your name, sent via tiaki or your own mailbox: with double opt-in, recorded consent and one-click unsubscribe.
Learn more GuidesThe best time to post on Instagram: how to find your own
The best time to post on Instagram is your own: how to find it in Instagram Insights, test it and schedule your posts in advance.
Learn more GuidesContent plan template: how to plan your social media month
Social media content plan template: the columns you need, sample weeks for a bakery and an agency, and a monthly rhythm with awareness days to join in on.
Learn moreFancy trying it with tiaki?
Try it for 30 days and get started · All features